Skip to main content

straight answers →

How do you vet a lead provider for an accounting firm?

Ask every provider the same seven questions, and get the answers in writing: who else receives the lead, how it was generated, what counts as a bad lead, what happens when a prospect cancels or does not show, how you stop buying, whether what you have not used is lost, and whether you can get your money back. A good provider answers all seven plainly. The table shows our answers.

By Randall Hall, Co-Founder. Published . Updated .

the numbers →

Our answers to the seven questions

QuestionDIYBooked For You
Who else receives it?Shared with up to three firmsYours alone
How was it generated?A business owner completed a form asking for bookkeeping helpA discovery call with a business owner who asked to talk to a bookkeeper, placed on your calendar
What counts as a bad lead, and what do I get for one?An eligible dispute returns the lead to your balance, up to a set allowanceBad contact details, an abusive contact, spam or a fake inquiry, or someone who never inquired. An eligible dispute returns the credit to your balance
What if the prospect cancels or does not show?Not applicable: you call the lead yourselfIf the prospect cancels before the meeting starts, the credit returns automatically. If you cancel, or the prospect does not show, it stays spent
How do I stop buying?Month-to-month with no annual contract. Stop before the renewal date and your current period runs to its endNo contract and no monthly renewal. If Auto-refill is on, the account owner can turn it off in the Buyer Portal
Do I lose what I have not used?Unused leads roll into the next monthNo. Credits never expire
Can I get my money back?Payments are final under our Terms. In special circumstances we may choose to issue a one-time refund of up to one month of service, reviewed case by case and once per customerThe same rule applies

What should you ask about where the leads come from?

Ask what wording the person agreed to when they filled in the form, how recently the lead was generated, and what was checked before it reached you, such as a phone confirmation, a duplicate check or a check that the person really asked. The white paper lists these as the questions to put to any provider.

The checks matter most when a lead is sold as exclusive. The white paper warns that without rigorous checks, an exclusive lead can be the same low-quality contact you would have bought shared, at a higher price.

Ask, too, what a close rate you are quoted counts: leads, meetings held, or clients signed. A rate means little until you know.

What should you ask about exclusivity?

Ask who else receives the lead, and ask for the answer in plain words. Exclusive should mean one firm. Across the market, the white paper finds that a shared lead typically goes to three to ten buyers.

Our shared versus exclusive page sets out the difference.

What is the difference between shared and exclusive leads for accountants?

What should you ask about bad leads?

Ask what counts as a bad lead, how many you can send back, how long you have, and what you get: a replacement, a credit or money.

Our standard defaults: on DIY, up to 20% of the eligible leads you bought in a billing period, disputed in the period they were delivered, and bonus leads are not eligible. On Booked For You, up to two eligible disputes in any rolling 30 days, within 30 days of the meeting. Disputes inside your allowance are returned to your balance automatically, with no separate approval, and on DIY normal delivery can send another lead. Your Buyer Portal shows the allowance on your account.

A returned lead or credit goes back to your balance. It is not money back on your card.

What should you ask about no-shows?

If you buy meetings, ask who bears a no-show. The white paper puts the share of well-qualified meetings that actually take place at 75% to 85%, and of poorly qualified ones at 50% to 65%, so some meetings will not be held. A meeting that does not take place is still paid for.

We say our rule plainly: on Booked For You a no-show does not return the credit. Pretending a no-show costs nothing is how lead prices get inflated to cover it.

What should you ask about stopping and refunds?

Ask whether there is a contract, how you stop, what you lose when you stop, and whether a payment can be refunded. Ask for the answers in the terms you will sign, and check that the website, the terms and the welcome email say the same thing.

more questions →

What else do people ask?

Is a credit return the same as a refund?

No. A credit return puts a lead or meeting credit back in your account. It does not send money to your card. Cash refunds follow the separate rule in our Terms.

Where are your rules written down?

On our returns and cancellations page and in our Terms of Service. The allowance for your own account is shown in your Buyer Portal.

What if I turn on Auto-refill and change my mind?

The account owner can turn it off in the Buyer Portal under Billing, in the relevant credit wallet, and the setting saves immediately. Closing your calendar pauses bookings. It does not turn off Auto-refill.

Is a lead or a meeting a guaranteed client?

No. A lead is an opportunity to begin a sales conversation. It is not a guaranteed appointment or a guaranteed client.

sources and method →

Where do these figures come from?

  • Our rules are the ones on our returns and cancellations page and in our Terms of Service. The limits shown are the standard defaults, and your Buyer Portal shows the allowance on your account.
  • The questions about how leads are generated, the number of buyers per shared lead and the share of meetings that take place come from our Lead Conversion Intelligence white paper (May 2026), Table 03.1, Table 05.1, Section 04 and Section 05. They are benchmarks compiled from published industry research, not measurements of Booked For You results.
  • Nothing on this page is a promise of a client or a result.

Not sure which route fits?

The two-minute quiz recommends DIY or Booked For You based on your firm.