straight answers →
Should a bookkeeper buy leads?
Buy leads if three things are true: you can call a new lead within minutes, you will follow up many times, and you know what a new client is worth to you. If one is missing, fix that first, because the leads will not make up for it. Our Lead Conversion Intelligence white paper (May 2026) finds that results depend less on the leads than on what the buyer does with them.
By Randall Hall, Co-Founder. Published . Updated .
the numbers →
Three checks before you buy
| Check | What good looks like | What the white paper says |
|---|---|---|
| Speed | You call back within minutes, and within the first minute for a shared lead | Firms that contact a shared lead within 30 seconds convert at 8% to 10%. Firms that wait 2 minutes or more typically fall to 3% to 5%. |
| Follow-up | You make several attempts over a couple of weeks, not a single call | It takes 6 to 12 touches to book a meeting in most business-to-business settings, and most businesses make fewer than two attempts before giving up. |
| What a client is worth | You know what a new client pays you over the time you keep them | A healthy ratio is a client lifetime value of at least 3 times the cost of winning the client. |
What do you need in place before you buy?
Speed, follow-up and a number. Speed, because when three firms get the same inquiry, the one who calls back first usually wins it. Follow-up, because one call rarely does the job. And a number, because you cannot tell whether leads are worth it until you know what a client is worth to you.
The white paper's advice is to build the way you respond first, before you buy volume.
How do you know if a lead is worth what it costs?
Work out your cost per client: what you spend on leads divided by the clients you sign. The white paper calls this cost per acquisition and says it is the only number that matters, because the price of a single lead can mislead.
Then set it against what a client is worth to you. The paper's example for bookkeeping: a client kept for 24 months at $500 a month is worth $12,000, so up to $4,000 to win that client still leaves a three to one ratio. That is an illustration, not a prediction. Use your own fees and how long your clients stay.
Our lead price page shows the white paper's estimates of what a client costs from each kind of lead.
Should leads replace referrals?
No. The white paper reports referrals as the highest-converting source it covers, and notes that the most successful accounting firms invest heavily in referrals instead of relying only on purchased leads. Treat leads as an addition to referrals, not a replacement for them.
What would it cost to try?
Our DIY leads cost about $20 to $31 each depending on the plan, shared with up to three firms. Our DIY plans are month-to-month with no annual contract, and unused leads roll into the next month.
Booked For You meetings cost $150 to $200 each and are yours alone. There is no contract, and credits never expire.
more questions →
What else do people ask?
Is a purchased lead a guaranteed client?
No. A lead is an opportunity to begin a sales conversation. It is not a guaranteed appointment or a guaranteed client.
What if I cannot call back right away?
Then a shared lead is a poor fit. A Booked For You meeting is already on your calendar and is yours alone, so there is no race to call back.
When is the best time to buy leads?
The white paper says tax-season leads (January to April) move fastest and close most often. New businesses need bookkeeping at once, and year-end leads (October to December) are slower but can have high lifetime value if converted.
Which should I try first, DIY or Booked For You?
DIY sends you leads and you work them. Booked For You books meetings on your calendar and you close them. The two-minute quiz recommends one based on your firm.
sources and method →
Where do these figures come from?
- Our prices are read live from the Booked By Friday price list and shown to the nearest dollar, and a price that has been rounded is marked "about".
- The cost-per-client rule, the lifetime-value example, the number of touches and the speed benchmark come from our Lead Conversion Intelligence white paper (May 2026), Table 03.1, Section 02, Section 08 and Section 10. The referral finding is from Table 07.1, and the timing of tax-season, new-business and year-end leads is from Section 07. They are benchmarks compiled from published industry research, not measurements of Booked By Friday results.
- The DIY and Booked For You terms are the ones on our program pages.
- Nothing on this page is a promise of a client or a result.
More answers
- How much do bookkeeping leads cost?
- How much does a booked meeting cost for accountants?
- What is the difference between shared and exclusive leads for accountants?
- What close rate is normal for bookkeeping leads?
- How do you vet a lead provider for an accounting firm?
- How fast should you call a new bookkeeping lead?
- What is the difference between pay-per-lead and pay-per-meeting for accountants?
Not sure which route fits?
The two-minute quiz recommends DIY or Booked For You based on your firm.